sgelhau
UKC Forum Member
Registered: Aug 2014
Location: Jay County, Indiana
Posts: 34 |
Re: Private Message
[QUOTE]Originally posted by Rowdy
[B]I got a private message from a Hunter asking why I didn't pull Jazz off the tree and send her on to find the coon. He stated that he had always been told that this is what needs to be done when a dog slick trees. There was no mean spirit or know it all attitude about the message, he just wanted to know why I didn't send her on. I figure if he asked more may be wondering the same thing. First, I will go into more detail about what happened and then I will list my reasoning.
After Jazz located the first time, I really started watching the Garmin. I knew it was not the typical and normal locate of the confident young dog I was hunting. She had also really been putting some time between opening on the track prior to the half hearted locate. I knew then she was bogged down. Watching the Garmin I knew she was not giving up even the going got tough. She worked all the way around, back and forth and around and round. When she came back to the tree she thought she had it and was gambling.
I know from experience ther are no perfect dogs. There are also many dogs that won't take a chance and gamble a bit. I was happy to see that she was willing to take chance and roll the dice so to speak. The tracking conditions here are tough even for an older more experienced hound. I'm not making excuses but let's consider it in another way.
You coach a youth basketball team and you are down by two with ten seconds to go. Your boys bring the ball up the court, do you want them to wait for the perfect shot and let the clock run out or take chance and put the ball up? Would you want them to hold the ball and let the clock run out because they were afraid they would miss? If they shot the ball and missed would you scold them for taking a reasonable shot or would you praise them for taking a courageous chance?
Let's bring this back to Jazz. Accuracy has not been an issue with this pup. In fact she is probably too cautious at times or slow to pull the trigger. I saw this as a reasonable mistake on one hand but a victory on the other. In the Marine Corps we used to use the saying "Good Initiative, Bad Judgement". This was a way of celebrating a courageous decision but pointing out that it did not work out with the desired result. You can teach a task but developing character is more important.
When it comes to training dogs or people for that matter, one must consider the big picture. It would be easy to ruin the spirit for punishing simple mistakes. Jazz has demonstrated excellence in the accuracy department so far. So the question is do we worry about one mistake that is part of a bigger success? The answer in my mind is no.
We as trainers, make the mistake of putting these pups in a "box". If they aren't doing such and such by this age they are culls, if they make this mistake you gotta do this, if you let them get by with this even one time, you will always have problems etc. etc. I always try to see the training sessions as a whole. Weigh the goods and the bads. Break it down to its individual parts.
In the case of last night I will list the positives:
1)Hunted out 1200 yards to find a track
2) opened according to the track ( didn't bark just to bark)
3) moved the track well
4) didn't quit
5) showed courage to take the shot
The Bad:
1) she missed
So the question remains why I didn't send her on to get it right. I knew that she has worked her tail off to get where she was. I knew there would be no benefit to cutting her in that area. She had covered it thoroughly and this is the best she could do.
To wrap this up, let's go back to our basketball analogy: after the game is over do you look at your young rising star and say " hey nice effort BUT you have to shoot 100 three pointers and run a lap for everyone you miss"? Or do you say, "Hey that was close, you played your butt off. We'll get em next time!"
Very well put more hunters should take the whole scenario into account like this before passing judgement. Thanks for passing along your experience and wisdom. I enjoy this thread a lot and I know many other hunters do as well.
__________________
'PR' Hagermans Blue Speck
Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged
|