UKC Forums - Bench show judge

	UKC Website :: Hunting Ops :: All-Breed Sports :: Registration :: UKC Online Store

UKC Forums : Powered by vBulletin version 2.3.0

UKC Forums > Departments > UKC Coonhounds > Bench show judge

In larger shows such as winterclassic autumn oaks etc what would be better ? You do not have permission to vote on this poll.
3 judge panel	36	67.92%
1 judge	17	32.08%
Total:	53 votes	100%

[Edit Poll (moderators only)]

Pages (2): « 1 [2]

Last Thread Next Thread

Author

Thread

Robert Johnson
UKC Forum Member

Registered: Dec 2006
Location: Springfield, Ga.
Posts: 4252

regardless of a 3 person panel or 100 person, their vote is still their opinion any way you slice it.

__________________
Robert " Rock" Johnson

Johnson Creek Kennels
home of:
UKC Grand Nite Champion "PR" Yadkin River Addkis. Deceased 12/11/2016 RIP

2009/2010/2011/2012 AKC GA. State Leader and Supreme Grand Nite Champion Yadkin River Addkis

2010 ACHA Georgia State Champion Grand Nite Champion Yadkin River Addkis

PKC Champion Yadkin River Addkis

Bright Eye Lights

Treeing Walkers

912-663-5287 cell (perfered)

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

02-19-2018 12:02 PM

Click here to Send Robert Johnson a Private Message

Kanen r23
UKC Forum Member

Registered: Feb 2018
Location: GA
Posts: 50

True

Facts 3 heads are better than one

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

02-19-2018 02:05 PM

Click here to Send Kanen r23 a Private Message

wjoey
Banned

Registered: Oct 2010
Location: La fayette Georgia
Posts: 2144

quote:
Originally posted by Robert Johnson
Just as I suspected. OPINIONS! yours and theirs. A show is only as good as the dogs in it and the judge. YOU PAID AN ENTRY FEE to get THAT ONE JUDGES OPINION for that day. Every judge is looking for that one little thing they consider to be the deciding thing. As you stated before, you won, but in your opinion you should not have. Guess what? It wasn't your opinion that counted that day. Be glad of it and move on. Panels could work, if they all are judge qualified, but just like the hunt director panels, anyone an sit on them and make judgments. Sad thing is they don't have to be qualified or even have a clue what they are doing to make that decision. Believe me, the show folks want none of that arena. They have enough squabbles as it is now.

Like you Rock I dont need any help judging dogs if I did I would quit. I have judged as many as 75 at a show and never gave my decisions a second thought .

__________________
JOE WILBANKS
423-802-4115
The home where the big time winners come from

UKC PREFORMANCE SIRE Nt ch pkc ch BAM BAM The only one out of WORLD CH BIG D X GRNT SKIPPERS UMFORGIVEN SAIGE she has 21 pups 4nt ch 5 grnt ch thats 42.85%
He is a coon dog!
Nt ch ch Insane Minnie MouseInsane cain x Malden Branch Mouse

HOME OF 2 TIME AQHA HORSE OF THE YEAR
World champion working cow horse snaffle bit
SMART LITTLE LEGEND
ETCHA CHAMPION
HCHA CHAMPION
Top 16 NCHA WORLD Champion
Home of GHSRA All Around Cowboy Champion Chris wilbanks

Jerico Rebel our Movie star horse hes been in three films now 35 years old
Just passed away February 4th 2016

MY OLD DOGS GONE BUT NEVER FORGOTTEN
The one I will allways miss now deceased 01/09/2013
GR CH GRAND NT CH Handosme Trudy
SIRE PKC WLD CH GR NT WHATS UP DOC
DAM GR NT HUTCHINS SUGAR

GRCH GR NT CH COBBLER CREEK WENDY
GR NT STYLISH TUFF - WENDY X STYLISH LIPPER
GR NT STYLISH TACK - WENDY X STYLISH LIPPER

NT CH SOUTHERN STYLE - JP'S HIGH STYLE X HOUSES LADY

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

02-19-2018 04:05 PM

Click here to Send wjoey a Private Message

Robert Johnson
UKC Forum Member

Registered: Dec 2006
Location: Springfield, Ga.
Posts: 4252

Re: True

quote:
Originally posted by Kanen r23
Facts 3 heads are better than one

NOT FACT...Myth... Everyone says that, but nothing is further from fact. In some cases, it can be true, but it really depends on who's heads are counting. No 3 on here will ever be as good as the one head who cuts open people, and some on here will never measure up to just one on here. All depends on the head.

I look at this as I do some panels I have witnessed on the hunt side. When you have 3 that have no clue, that one person that does is far better to make a decision, but they normally get out voted by the less educated, and that is very sad indeed. Makes for a big mess.

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

02-20-2018 12:21 PM

H. L. Meyer
UKC Forum Member

Registered: Sep 2003
Location: Fayetteville.Ga
Posts: 2167

Last post PERIOD

At a big major event, 3 judge panel I was on no discussion before the judging began no issues at all then the final announcement was made on the overall winner, ALL three of us were standing together announcement made we looked at each other and said how did that one win none of us picked it to win. FUNNY THINGS HAPPEN SOME TIMES 3 might not be the answer. works really well with a K/Q overall pick. Don't agree with Rock on some things BUT he may be spot on here.
BY BY gone

__________________
SHAWNEE HILL'S BLACK AND TANS

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

02-20-2018 01:42 PM

Click here to Send H. L. Meyer a Private Message

Buckshot
UKC Forum Member

Registered: Jun 2003
Location: ALABAMA
Posts: 5183

Re: Last post PERIOD

quote:
Originally posted by H. L. Meyer
At a big major event, 3 judge panel I was on no discussion before the judging began no issues at all then the final announcement was made on the overall winner, ALL three of us were standing together announcement made we looked at each other and said how did that one win none of us picked it to win. FUNNY THINGS HAPPEN SOME TIMES 3 might not be the answer. works really well with a K/Q overall pick. Don't agree with Rock on some things BUT he may be spot on here.
BY BY gone

So did any of you 3 say anything about it or just let it ride? So who picked the dog as the overall winner since the three of you didn't? That is not a sometimes 3 is not the answer...........that's cheating and if 3 spoke up that day, should have been solved.

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

02-20-2018 03:13 PM

Click here to Send Buckshot a Private Message

Richard Lambert
UKC Forum Member

Registered: Aug 2004
Location: Chattanooga, Tn
Posts: 22586

3 judge panel and all 3 pick a different dog to win? Just shows how objective bench show judging can be. All three must pick a first, second and third. If all 3 pick a different first but all 3 pick the same second place then that dog wins.

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

02-20-2018 03:33 PM

Click here to Send Richard Lambert a Private Message

thomasg
UKC Forum Member

Registered: Apr 2014
Location: batsville ark
Posts: 1110

i only had one that i trained for the bench . when i turned the handling over to my 8 year old daughter he was never beat . was he the best dog shown that day ? to be honest i would have to say no . lol a score card with points awarded and deducted for conformation and breed standards should be used in bench shows that could be seen by all who enter and watch shows . then everyone could see why the judge made his choices and formed his opinion for the winners .

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

02-20-2018 04:25 PM

Click here to Send thomasg a Private Message

kelly601lee
UKC Forum Member

Registered: Aug 2009
Location: New Florence PA
Posts: 246

Panel

The only time I prefer a panel is for overall king/queen, especially at an event where there is a full show 2 days, like most breed days have a show Friday and Saturday. For example, you show Friday you win your category, you get to come back for Saturday overall. If you also choose to show in the show on Saturday and that judge does not pick your dog, it's kind of pointless to show for king/queen if it's the same judge picking.

__________________
Kelly Myers
Laurel Valley Kennel
New Florence PA

Proud home of:

WSHOWCH GRCH 'PR' Laurel Valley Backwoods Boondocker
*2014 SETWA Overall Show Champion
*2014 PA State Championship Overall Show Winner
*2014 Autumn Oaks Champion Male of Breed
*2015 Autumn Oaks Champion Male of Breed
*2016 Walker Days Saturday Grand Champion Male
*2016 Purina Points Breed Winner
*2017 AKC World Show Champion
*2017 UKC World Show Champion
*2018 Grand American GRCH Male

'PR' Lost Heritage Laurel Valley Liv
*2017 SETWA Overall Show Champion

GRCH 'PR' Laurel Hill Largo Stardom Bound
*2014 Walkers Days Overall Show Champion
*2014 PA State Championship Opp Sex Winner
*2015 Grand American Opp Sex Winner