john nannemann
UKC Forum Member
Registered: May 2008
Location: southcentral arkansas
Posts: 1571 |
Re: Re: Goverment stuck us retired older folks
quote: Originally posted by truly
Now, I am under the assumption that you are human being, a member of my society [The United States of America], and not just a paid propogandist working for some corporation. I believe in working together [John calls it collectivism] to care for citizens of my society. John calls that socialism. I call it traditional Judeo-Christian values. Those values tell me that we would be best to tax more heavily the super rich to care for working class. [John would call that marxism]. I believe that we should quit bailing out the capitalists and start caring for the working class. Now some would say that I am "redistributing wealth", but if you worked hard all your life, didn't you in fact help create that wealth that the millionaires have? Why should the CEO of a for profit health insurance company make hundreds of thousands of dollars a day, while a guy who maybe cut wood or mined for coal, or farmed their whole life would have to work for 10 years to make what a CEO might make in a day? Are these people better than you? More worthy than you? Do they deserve to live the good life more than you?
I think not.
1st, i would call it the names that it IS- which you have so graciously posted for me above.
2nd- coersion/compulsion are not Judeo/Christian values- charity is.
3rd- the top 1%(of which i am not part of) are already paying 40% of all the income taxes and many are helping keep the jobs going to collect the remaining 60%.
4th- i ALSO think we should stop bailing out SO CALLED capitalists( i agree with you!!! thats 2) BUT- i think the so called "working class"(of which i'm a part of) should try to get a better handle on why their compensation is what it is.
5th- if the ceo is COMPETENT- makes a return on investment for the shareholders of the company, is able to "run" the company in a way that many people derive their paychecks from it, then yes, he is "worth" it, THE OWNERS OF THE COMPANY have deemed it so. the guy that cut wood, mined coal, or farmed did not generate the same ECONOMIC impact. if competent ceo's were dripping from trees, they wouldn't get paid as much. SIMPLE economics. see "economic lesson" below.
6th- not necessarily better "people", but obviously "better" economically, more "worthy" ECONOMICALLY, and may or may not "live a better life" then you or me depending on your definition of said "better life". i personally like my life, i work to make enough to support my family, i get to go coon hunting, i'm not responsible for many folks livelyhood. go read your history of the early soviet union's problems when they had killed off the traders and the managers. stalin effectively said ''hey, this crap is HARD''.
economic lesson-
truly, et al.
do you not understand the purchaser of a product or service ultimately determines the "value" of the "labor" held inside said product or service?
teaching moment example- jasper johns can spread some beeswax and pigment onto a board into a picture of a "bullseye" and the purchaser values his "labor'' into the millions of dollars. you can go to walmart and buy a whole package of bullseyes for about 5 bucks. the purchaser of these has determined the value of not just each of these bullseye's- a few cents each, but also the value of getting it there and having it there went desired(carrying costs). at their most basic, their both pictures of bullseyes, but a huge difference in what the purchasers value them at. without some return on investment, there is no incentive to invest in making anything. consume what is available and then STARVE.
logic fun- if the means of control in an authoritarian government system is starvation- and it is- then the logical end to starvation is DEATH. so in the end, the authoritarian, collectivist, arbitrary government forms contain an implicit "death threat". the ideology of death.
Last edited by john nannemann on 12-19-2009 at 02:27 PM
Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged
|