Oak Ridge
UKC Forum Member
Registered: Aug 2003
Location: Indiana
Posts: 6168 |
quote: Originally posted by blueticker
When you hear the judge say," I am not picking the best looking dog on the bench but the one that gates the best". Why don't we call it a gaiting show and not a bench show. The gaiting deal just allows the judge anouther out to be political. The political deal goes from the local club clear to the top. The title should read, "Who's Who in coonhound showing". There is a few judges that will still select the dog and not the handler.
If that is an accusation that by looking at the dogs gait, to establish a foundation for what you see and feel on the bench.....I (as one of the judges that judges the WHOLE dog) as being "political"....you might need to read the rules.
UKC Bench Show Rules:
30. "Dogs must be evaluated both while gaited and shown on the bench. In order to properly evaluate the coonhound, the dog must be compared to the standard on the bench to assess its conformation and then gaited to determine the efficiency and athleticism of the dog’s locomotion."
It's not a beauty contest...it is a conformation event.....and as far as I am concerned.....by using gaiting, and evaluating the gait, and doing some of the evaluation of the dogs on the ground...I'm taking the handler OUT of the equation. The rules are clear....evaluation of locomotion is a part of the competition, and I don't see anywhere where the beauty portion is "more important".
A "good" handler can cover up all manner of poor conformation on a bench, a feat that is darn near impossible when the dog is moving across the ring.....
I don't show dogs, and I could not possibly care any less about "who" wins....I don't follow the politics of showing, and I'm about to send in my judges card because I get tired of the accusations that judges are political......
Simple fact is that knowing the breed standards, understanding structure, and some good old fashioned "stock sense" is what makes a good judge....and comments such as the one above run more "good judges" off.....and create the scenario where the politicos are the only ones left.
__________________
Joe Newlin
UKC Cur Advocate
Home of Oak Ridge Kennels
Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged
|