Tarascon
UKC Forum Member
Registered: Aug 2003
Location: Kentucky
Posts: 828 |
quote: Originally posted by l.lyle
None of us are pharmasists I recon. If you want to put Nitrogen in your garden Urea and Amonia are two N sources that are less than 50% N.. Why don't they make a 100% product? If they did you couldnt handle it. Alot of products have inert ingredients in them to make it easier to handle and mix. Most of the time they are either water, alchohol or an oil.
Imidacloprid is LABELLED to be used on trees and shrubs and Roses and Flowers. The product was very likely not developed to be used on those plants, it was developed to kill certain insects. It finally got LABELLED, after EPA scrutiny, to be used on non-edible plants. Imidacloprid is used on cereal and grain crops, vegetables, coffee, Brazil nuts etc. in other countries. Which we probably eat.
If the target is an insect, to some extent to which it is applied to plant Vs animal is questionable since an insect is neither. For that matter, which specific animal? If you wash out a cat kennel with pine oil you can have a dead cat while it won't hurt a dog at all. Alot of it depends on the experiece of others
If you use a product for which it was not labelled and your dog dies, good luck with your lawsuit, even if you press charges you will likely be the one in jail. Every day you see commercials by Shyster lawyers suing a drug company for something and trying to tell you if you ever took that drug you ought to jump on the bandwagon knowing full well that Pennecillin killed more people than even took the new drug they're suing over.
You make some very good points for eating organic, or at least growing your own food and knowing what has been put on it. I'm a bit confused about your plant vs animal argument, though. I've got no problem with using Advantage on one of my dogs, just don't think it's a good idea to treat him like a shrub.
You are absolutely right that using a chemical off label would make it impossible to go after the manufacturer.
__________________
Yvonne Moore
Henry County, Kentucky
~Tarascon Working Terriers~
GREWCH CH Corn Row Busy AWTA Veteran Earthdog CG
CH Huntmoor Reiver AWTA WCs CG
CH Tarascon Walker
GREWCH Tarascon Bailey JRTCA Bronze, AWTA Veteran, RIP my special girl.
~Bailey is the only terrier in the country to have earned the highest hunting honors in three working terrier programs~
CH Tarascon Jessie JRTCA NHC, RIP
Smoky Mountain Hillbilly AWTA WC, RIP Billy, we miss you
~and Silken Windhounds!~
~CH 'PR' WindnSatin Smoke 'n Water (Arwen)~
and
~CH 'PR' Hunters Run Cuda (Holly)~
Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged
|