UKC Forums - Score this Plus or Minus ???

Pages (3): [1] 2 3 »
Show all 69 posts from this thread on one page

UKC Forums (http://forums.ukcdogs.com/index.php)
- UKC Coonhounds (http://forums.ukcdogs.com/forumdisplay.php?forumid=4)
-- Score this Plus or Minus ??? (http://forums.ukcdogs.com/showthread.php?threadid=486288)

Posted by longshot on 02-26-2012 10:07 PM:

Score this Plus or Minus ???

Here's a couple pics of a Lay-up coon treed by wind only. The question is , do you plus or minus these dogs ?

Picture #1 : Some statistics to go with this picture are : The coon is 15 feet straight above the dog. The dog is 40 feet from the base of tree the coon went up.

__________________________________________________
_

Picture # 2: Some statistics on this picture are : The dog is on a bluff at eye level with the coon. The coon is 25 feet from the dog.

NOW , go vote in the poll on one of the FOUR possible scores.

__________________
Mark Reavis
Southwest Missouri
Dual Grand Champion Super Sambo

Posted by longshot on 02-26-2012 10:12 PM:

And in case you're wondering , no I can't take credit for a four year old's drawings. ... But they do Illustrate the scenarios very well.

__________________
Mark Reavis
Southwest Missouri
Dual Grand Champion Super Sambo

Posted by JiM on 02-26-2012 10:34 PM:

Interesting scenarios. I voted minus 1 and plus 2. Neet question.

__________________
UKC Nite Champion Stylish Harry's Trixie - 2017 World Hunt Qualified - Owners - Sizemore/Martin
PKC CH/UKC GrNtCh Stylish Kate - 9/12/08 to 9/23/2016 R.I.P - Owners Sizemore/Martin
AKC/UKC NtCh Sizemore's Timber Jam Jeff 5/2/2000 to 1/22/2012 R.I.P.
AKC/UKC GrNtCh Sizemore's Timber Jam Jessi 12/21/04 to 1/21/2011 R.I.P.

Posted by GA DAWG on 02-26-2012 11:10 PM:

Minus 1 for sure. Can't decide on 2. Id have to really see it happen. Im undecided until Im forced to vote

__________________
Michael Ghorley

Posted by david hicks on 02-26-2012 11:15 PM:

are you this bored?

__________________
David
1-417-229-0068
GRNITECH 'PR' MISSOURI'S COON CRAZY DOLLAR (KATE X BIG CREEK REBEL)
GRNITECH 'PR' ESSARY'S DUDLEY (KATE X RUDD'S NIGHT TRAIN){RIP}
'PR' COON CRAZY LITTLE KATE(KJ X PR STYLISH COMA'S BIG TICKET) LOTS OF COMA
CH GRNITECH 'PR' MISSOURI'S COON CRAZY KATE [ RIP ]

Posted by Bob Hennessey on 02-26-2012 11:19 PM:

I have a question. For those that minused the dog in #1 If there wasn't a tree under the coon and the dog was sitting directly under the coon would you plus it? In both scenarios the dogs is winding the coon. Dog #1 is 10 feet closer to the coon then #2.

__________________
Ignorance: the lack of knowledge, education, etc.
Stupidity: lacking normal intelligence.
Intelligence: the ability to learn or understand.
You can't fix STUPID!

Posted by patches9452 on 02-26-2012 11:20 PM:

in my opinion there is no way to plus one its slick.... two i would plus because the dog is showing the tree the coon is up.... iff i saw it in real life my verdict might be different but going just from the pics thats how i would do it

Posted by patches9452 on 02-26-2012 11:22 PM:

quote:
Originally posted by The Seeker
I have a question. For those that minused the dog in #1 If there wasn't a tree under the coon and the dog was sitting directly under the coon would you plus it? In both scenarios the dogs is winding the coon. Dog #1 is 10 feet closer to the coon then #2.

yes if there was no tree i would plus... the problem is there is a tree.... if not he would be showing the correct tree so i would vote to plus

Posted by kayapellijed390 on 02-26-2012 11:52 PM:

I agree minus 1 and plus 2. If the dog had sat on his butt on the first one instead of standing on another tree then I would say plus it. But if he trees on a tree that does not touch the tree with the coon I see no way to plus it. I have a dog right now who is excellant at treeing layups like that. But usually he just stands or sits under the coon and trees. I have had him get minused more than once for stuff like that, everytime it happens he is the only dog in the cast who even knows there is a coon there.

__________________
Lonetree Kennels "Where dogs are made one tree at a time."
Home of-
David and Jessica Smith 605-270-2674
GRNITECH 'PR' DERBY CITY SANDY
GRNITECH GRCH CASH'S CAMO JUG OF SHINE
--2012 National Grand Nite Champion American Leopard Hound
--High Scoring Leopard 2012 Autumn Oaks
--High scoring Leopard Saturday night at Leopard days 2011
--Qualified for the 2011 UKC World Hunt.
--High Scoring Leopard of the 2011 UKC World Hunt
--Breed Winner for the 2011 Purina Race Hunt
--2011 South Dakota State Hunt Champion
CH RYLEIGH'S GRIM REAPER
--Tri-State Coonhunters Association 2010 Bench show dog of the year

And the Redbone--
2013 Tri-State Overall Bench Show Dog of the Year:
'PR' CH RAGGED RIDGE CJ (Willie) co-owned with Bob Julson

Posted by kayapellijed390 on 02-27-2012 12:02 AM:

funny how the over half that say to plus the second tree seem to magically change to 75% say no in a four dog cast when it isn't there dog treeing the coon. LOL

Posted by jjlute on 02-27-2012 12:03 AM:

I voted to minus 1 and plus 2 but I could understand minusing both cuz the dog isn't on a tree but it looks like he's showing the tree to me #1 gotta be a minus cuz trees r not touching but if there were grapevines or whatever from tree to tree then id plus it #1 is a tuff deal but they are clearly not touching

__________________
LATE NITE OUTLAWS & TEAM RAMBLER
R.I.P. WTDA WORLD CHAMPION, PKC CHAMPION, UKC GRANDNITE CHAMPION, SHOW CHAMPION, 'PR' PURDY'S WOOD ROCKIN' RAMBLER HTX (PRIVATE TREATY) ($2,000 WON IN PKC)

RIP : GRNITECH 'PR' HARDWOOD HOLLY - 2012 Ashland Bluetick Days Friday Nite Ch Winner and double cast winner, 2012 WTDA Grand National Champion

JJ Lute - 330-987-7125

"Speed is great, accuracy is EVERYTHING" - Wyatt Erp

Posted by Gentry's English on 02-27-2012 12:16 AM:

quote:
Originally posted by The Seeker
I have a question. For those that minused the dog in #1 If there wasn't a tree under the coon and the dog was sitting directly under the coon would you plus it? In both scenarios the dogs is winding the coon. Dog #1 is 10 feet closer to the coon then #2.

I would plus it if it was not on a tree that did not have a coon in it. A dog that will tree a layup should be down wind of the coon with with its nose in the air I dont care if it just stands there or sits there but if it is barking up a tree that dont have a coon in it then its lieing to you telling you it went up that tree......

__________________
Gary Gentry

_________________________________

GRCH PR Oney's Indian Creek Big Echo (GR NT CH Oney's Outback Dan X Oney's Pearl) 2013 World Qualifier

Posted by Gentry's English on 02-27-2012 12:22 AM:

quote:
Originally posted by kayapellijed390
I agree minus 1 and plus 2. If the dog had sat on his butt on the first one instead of standing on another tree then I would say plus it. But if he trees on a tree that does not touch the tree with the coon I see no way to plus it. I have a dog right now who is excellant at treeing layups like that. But usually he just stands or sits under the coon and trees. I have had him get minused more than once for stuff like that, everytime it happens he is the only dog in the cast who even knows there is a coon there.

I agree 100% with you.... I too have a dog that will layup a coon and just sit there or stand there. I think that it is a bunch of BS that people want to minus dogs for this sore losers IMO...........

__________________
Gary Gentry

_________________________________

GRCH PR Oney's Indian Creek Big Echo (GR NT CH Oney's Outback Dan X Oney's Pearl) 2013 World Qualifier

Posted by davidlloyd on 02-27-2012 12:24 AM:

Had a dog tree like pic one wrong tree no points

__________________
GrNitech'Pr' Thunder Guns Ruby2 (TopGunXRuby)

Posted by Jason Baldwin on 02-27-2012 12:28 AM:

Regardless of rules, points, or anything such as that, those dogs have NOSE, BRAINS, and true winding ability. Many times my old blue female would tree coons like that. Those type dogs are the most accurate dogs of all because they dont rely on scent on a tree trunk !

Posted by CWT on 02-27-2012 12:41 AM:

I am not a competition hunter but I would say plus the first one and the second one. In my opinion if the dog is treeing by the wind then that scent is falling straight down that tree. that dog does not know that there are two trees, his brain is telling him that then coon is straight up the tree he is on. I dont care how smart a dog is he is not going to figure out the coon is in a different tree when his nose is telling him the scent is coming down the tree he is on. and the coon is right above the tree he is on. Just one more reason I would rather pleasure hunt. both those dogs have the coon no matter what way you look at it.

Posted by kayapellijed390 on 02-27-2012 01:07 AM:

quote:
Originally posted by CWT
I am not a competition hunter but I would say plus the first one and the second one. In my opinion if the dog is treeing by the wind then that scent is falling straight down that tree. that dog does not know that there are two trees, his brain is telling him that then coon is straight up the tree he is on. I dont care how smart a dog is he is not going to figure out the coon is in a different tree when his nose is telling him the scent is coming down the tree he is on. and the coon is right above the tree he is on. Just one more reason I would rather pleasure hunt. both those dogs have the coon no matter what way you look at it.

I disagree I don't care how long ago the coon climbed the tree their would be some coon scent on the tree. A dog might not be able to run a track into that tree, but if the dog actually trees on wood he should be able to check the trunk for scent first. If he can't find coon scent on a trunk somewhere then he should just position himself where he can smell the coon the best and then let me know about it. I could be way off and giving dogs more credit than they deserve but I have personally watched a dog do something real similar to this.

Posted by Virgil on 02-27-2012 01:24 AM:

By the rules dog 1 has to be minused and there is no way around it. He is on a slick tree with a coon in a nearby tree that is not touching.

I also voted to minus dog 2 but that one I would have to see the situation in the woods to rule on it.

__________________
Golden Woods Bo
Golden Woods Fancy B

Posted by Dale Young on 02-27-2012 01:38 AM:

Pleasure hunting and scoring with a 22 I'd say both were right but when you pull out the rule book I'd say #1 is minus because of the tree he's standing on not touching the one the coon is in.
#2 is showing coon with no other tree involved.
Only problem is the rule book but you got to write them somehow even if they don't always work like you think they should and I'm not a believer in changing rules unless you have one that doesn't work a large percentage of the time.

Posted by curtis hansley on 02-27-2012 01:52 AM:

Re: Score this Plus or Minus ???

quote:
Originally posted by longshot
Here's a couple pics of a Lay-up coon treed by wind only. The question is , do you plus or minus these dogs ?

Picture #1 : Some statistics to go with this picture are : The coon is 15 feet straight above the dog. The dog is 40 feet from the base of tree the coon went up.

__________________________________________________
_

Picture # 2: Some statistics on this picture are : The dog is on a bluff at eye level with the coon. The coon is 25 feet from the dog.

NOW , go vote in the poll on one of the FOUR possible scores.

i would minus the dog on blank tree and plus the dog on the cliff looking at the coon treeing and want to know what he is off of because he had a head full of sence not to jump off.LOL.

Posted by damon shivers on 02-27-2012 02:04 AM:

depends

If dog in 1 is winding Co on but has feet on tree and is clearly treing at the soon I would plus him using comin sense blood line touched on this I will look for it tonight but if he showing the tree he's standing on were the soon is the minus again comin sense dog 2 if he's clearly treeing at soon and tree he's in then plus if he's treeing because he can't get down then minus again comin sense plays a big role here!

__________________
Ntch PR Shivers Rushcreek Shelly-Ntch Perry's Rushcreek OppyXMichells Val(passed)
Grnitech CH Wch PR Shivers Magic Buckeye-Grch Gnitech PR Dillions Smoken Blue MagicXNtch Shivers Rush Creek Shelly(passed)
ChPR Shivers Blue Belle-HoochX Shelly
Nitech Ch PR Shivers Magic Lead-MagicXHooker
Breeder and handler and half owner of Nitech Grch Grwch Grfch PR Rock Acres Brutus HTX sire MagicXShelly
Cali- Ch Wch Grnite Shivers Magic Buckeye x Dual Grand Tuff

Posted by curtis hansley on 02-27-2012 02:12 AM:

RULES

RULES CLEARLY SAY THE LIMBS HAVE TO BE TOUCHING OR ITS MINUS BUT IF THERES A CLIFF IN BETWEEN THE DOG AND A COON THEY BOTH SHOULD BE MINUS.THATS THE RULES.BUT PLEASURE HUNTING I WOULD SCORE WITH 22.LOL.

Posted by WVbluetickhunte on 02-27-2012 03:05 AM:

quote:
Originally posted by JiM
Interesting scenarios. I voted minus 1 and plus 2. Neet question.

I agree

__________________
http://www.boggscreekkennels.com/

BoggsCreek Kennels
Home of:
Our Walkers:
2012 COONDAWG OF THE YEAR GRCH
GRNITECH'PR'DD's Yadkin Nightime Lil Shadow
'PR'Boggs Creek Beuford

Our Blueticks:
GRCH'PR'BoggsCreek Northern Blue Alice-ukc 1st

RIP- GRNITECH'PR'AnthonyCreek Daisy May

'PR' BoggsCreek Big Albert-retired

Posted by Blue Iron on 02-27-2012 03:07 AM:

quote:
Originally posted by JiM
Interesting scenarios. I voted minus 1 and plus 2. Neet question.

Yep. He's "showing the tree"

Bad deal on the first one, but they don't touch.

__________________
Clyde Murphy 229-344-7308

GRCH GRNITECH"PR" Blue Iron Brummy HTX

Top 100 Finalist 2012 UKC World Hunt.

King of Hunt 2013 BBOA National Bluetick Days

Tree Blue

I use and recommend Backwoods Supplies

Posted by ronald schultz on 02-27-2012 03:42 AM:

#2 what if

the dog was standing with front feet on the big rock? /cliff ? treeing up at coon?

All times are GMT. The time now is 08:36 PM.

Pages (3): [1] 2 3 »
Show all 69 posts from this thread on one page