UKC Forums (http://forums.ukcdogs.com/index.php)
- UKC Coonhounds (http://forums.ukcdogs.com/forumdisplay.php?forumid=4)
-- How would you score this (http://forums.ukcdogs.com/showthread.php?threadid=928417079)

How would you score this

3 dog cast dog A strikes & trees dogs B&C are shut out on strike & dogs B&C come into tree after 5 min are up. Handlers of dog B&C strike and tree there dogs when they get to dogs A tree but 5 min is up. When cast gets to within 50 yards of tree dog A clearly barks on ground 4 or 5 barks about 20 yards behind tree then comes back to tree. I was handling dog A & I was judge. I minused dog A strike & tree 225- . Dog B struck& treed for 75& 75 dog C for 50 &50. I pulsed dog B strike 75 & moved his tree to 125 for 200+ and dog C strike50& tree 75 for 125+. I minused my dog dog A 125 for barking on ground then she came back to tree where coon was seen 100-.

So they WERE split from Dog A ? And Dog A came to their tree?

They treed on a close tree right

__________________
Brandon

was all this on the same tree? if so there are so many mistakes it's hard to keep things straight.

Your scores are correct,you just got there wrong.Once dog A's 5 minutes were up on his tree,dogs B and C had to take 125 and 75 when they treed in.By rule,once a tree is dead,any dog called treed is an automatic split tree call and as soon as dog a barked off B and C's points became good.

Ok lets try this, Dog A is struck for 100 and treed for 125. Dog A tree is dead, then dogs B and C were struck and treed. So Dog B is struck for 75 (shut out) and Treed which he goes in for 125 as a split tree because he treed after the five. Dog C is struck for 50 (shut out) and treed after dog A tree is dead but while dog B tree is running so he goes in for 75. Dog A was then seen off his tree so he gets -125, then goes back to tree( now most the time you need to know rather the judge was already at the tree when dog A goes back or if dog A was back at the tree before the Judge). Now this is how I would score it and many will disagree and I would like Allen or Cory to weigh in on this. Since dog A was seen Off his tree and -125 and dog B & C should have been taking as a split tree but were in fact with dog A. Dog B takes -125 dog C takes -75 as they left there split tree( on paper because they were never really split). So this makes the tree open and dogs should have been re-treed. Which would mean dogs B and C would now get there strike points because they are no longer shut out. It would now depend on the order dogs were re-treed. A coon was seen so all dogs would then be plus strike and tree.

__________________
Home of the Original Whiskey Hounds!
Rebecca Agee

quote:

---

Originally posted by River Birch Run
Ok lets try this, Dog A is struck for 100 and treed for 125. Dog A tree is dead, then dogs B and C were struck and treed. So Dog B is struck for 75 (shut out) and Treed which he goes in for 125 as a split tree because he treed after the five. Dog C is struck for 50 (shut out) and treed after dog A tree is dead but while dog B tree is running so he goes in for 75. Dog A was then seen off his tree so he gets -125, then goes back to tree( now most the time you need to know rather the judge was already at the tree when dog A goes back or if dog A was back at the tree before the Judge). Now this is how I would score it and many will disagree and I would like Allen or Cory to weigh in on this. Since dog A was seen Off his tree and -125 and dog B & C should have been taking as a split tree but were in fact with dog A. Dog B takes -125 dog C takes -75 as they left there split tree( on paper because they were never really split). So this makes the tree open and dogs should have been re-treed. Which would mean dogs B and C would now get there strike points because they are no longer shut out. It would now depend on the order dogs were re-treed. A coon was seen so all dogs would then be plus strike and tree.

---

Side note, when dogs are treed they always stay in the order they are treed unless you walk in and dogs are split. Exsample Dog A is treed for 125 B for 75 C for 50 and D for 25. When arriving at the tree dogs A and B are together and dogs C and D are together but split form A and B. Dog A stays at 125 Dog B stays at 75 Dog C moves up to 125 and dog D moves up to 75. No dog can be moved up on a tree once it is treed behind another dog unless it is split.

Handlers try this all the time say Dog A struck for 100 and treed for 125 and Dog B struck for 75 and treed for 75. The tree is dead and dog A left before judge arrives and is minus 125 then comes back to tree after the judge. A coon is seen. Handler of dog B will try to move his dog up to 125, then move dog A to next available tree at 75. Then minus dog A 75 tree and 100 strike. Giving dog A 300 minus. And dog B 200 plus. This is wrong Dog B should not move up.

__________________
Home of the Original Whiskey Hounds!
Rebecca Agee

quote:

---

Originally posted by DFred
Are you saying to score a tree that has already been scored? If the tree had been scored then it is dead and cannot be re-treed on.

---

__________________
Home of the Original Whiskey Hounds!
Rebecca Agee

Dogs B and C were holding a tree, that was shined, and had a coon. It was scored as if Dog A left it's tree and came to them. The question is was it actually one tree or split trees. Let's wait for that answer. Otherwise we are just speculating and adding to the confusion.

score as closed tree

fellas this is crazy but all dogs get minus here. dog a will recieve 225-. dog b 125 minus and dog c 75 minus for this reasoning. we all know dog a of course recieves 225-. now dog b and c were treed after the 5 on a closed tree. that means judge takes call as a split for 125 and 75. they were shut out on strike points. since same tree which was closed and coon seen dogs recieve minus tree points. since shut out on strike, strike points to be deleted. this will be in accordance with rule 4L and 5h and 3e.

Thats a tough one. One big mess and I could see it happening.. My question is what's considered judge arriving at the tree. Is it when you can see it? That could be 100 yards or more in winter.

__________________
Michael Ghorley

do you minus dog a's track points for leaving the tree? I thought the dog had to tree on a slick tree to get minus on strike and tree

__________________
Bent Creek Black and Tans
Aaron & Vicki Taylor 804-516-8137

pr Iowa import Deliela
grntch taylors black powder

quote:

---

Originally posted by GA DAWG
Thats a tough one. One big mess and I could see it happening.. My question is what's considered judge arriving at the tree. Is it when you can see it? That could be 100 yards or more in winter.

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by va.b&t
do you minus dog a's track points for leaving the tree? I thought the dog had to tree on a slick tree to get minus on strike and tree

---

if they were on same tree as dog a. then b and c would have strike with line under them . an both woulod have 125 minus for treeing on closed tree. an strike would b deleted for striking after a dog was treed.. if they were infact on seperate trees. then he did the right thing

__________________
home of;;;;
FCH NITECH GRCH'PR'BOYDS NOCTURNAL PEG[walker] RIP

GRNITE CH GRFCH GRCH'PR' ALL GRAND HARRYS MAN HTX 2 [walker]

GRCH FCH WCH PR HARRYS BIG BAD BOOMER HTX

NITECH CH VIRGINIAS MIGHTY MOE

quote:

---

Originally posted by River Birch Run
Ok lets try this, Dog A is struck for 100 and treed for 125. Dog A tree is dead, then dogs B and C were struck and treed. So Dog B is struck for 75 (shut out) and Treed which he goes in for 125 as a split tree because he treed after the five. Dog C is struck for 50 (shut out) and treed after dog A tree is dead but while dog B tree is running so he goes in for 75. Dog A was then seen off his tree so he gets -125, then goes back to tree( now most the time you need to know rather the judge was already at the tree when dog A goes back or if dog A was back at the tree before the Judge). Now this is how I would score it and many will disagree and I would like Allen or Cory to weigh in on this. Since dog A was seen Off his tree and -125 and dog B & C should have been taking as a split tree but were in fact with dog A. Dog B takes -125 dog C takes -75 as they left there split tree( on paper because they were never really split). So this makes the tree open and dogs should have been re-treed. Which would mean dogs B and C would now get there strike points because they are no longer shut out. It would now depend on the order dogs were re-treed. A coon was seen so all dogs would then be plus strike and tree.

---

wrong

wrong judge, if a tree is closed it does not ipen back up if dog a leaves if other dogs are already treed. strike is deleted.

.

Where is JiM when I need him.

Ain't nothing treed on that tree. Id 're tree mine right fast when I saw A leave.

__________________
Michael Ghorley

[QUOTE]Originally posted by River Birch Run
Ok lets try this, Dog A is struck for 100 and treed for 125. Dog A tree is dead, then dogs B and C were struck and treed. So Dog B is struck for 75 (shut out) and Treed which he goes in for 125 as a split tree because he treed after the five. Dog C is struck for 50 (shut out) and treed after dog A tree is dead but while dog B tree is running so he goes in for 75. Dog A was then seen off his tree so he gets -125, then goes back to tree( now most the time you need to know rather the judge was already at the tree when dog A goes back or if dog A was back at the tree before the Judge). Now this is how I would score it and many will disagree and I would like Allen or Cory to weigh in on this. Since dog A was seen Off his tree and -125 and dog B & C should have been taking as a split tree but were in fact with dog A. Dog B takes -125 dog C takes -75 as they left there split tree( on paper because they were never really split). So this makes the tree open and dogs should have been re-treed. Which would mean dogs B and C would now get there strike points because they are no longer shut out. It would now depend on the order dogs were re-treed. A coon was seen so all dogs would then be plus strike and tree. [/. I would minus A -225 , now to me the judge " did not see what tree A was on " just he's on the ground at first sight . Then B gets his 125 for treeing after a closed tree & C for 75 . So their strikes they would get too cause who knows A could have left his tree to come to theirs . So to me I would minus A -225 , B + 200 , C +125 Again they were never seen on A tree . Dog A was first seen on the ground so who knows exactly where he's treed .

To minus B and C for treeing after the 5 they have to be found treed with A. They were not and sense the judge did not determine that they were treed on the same tree as A then they are plussed.

__________________
Michael Rosamond
Sunspot Lights
936-827-6309
http://www.sunspotlights.com/
When brightness matters!!

Home Of:
PKC Ch, Grch Grnch 2008 Tx state champion They call me Crazy Betty

PKC SCh CH Grnch They call me Howler too

The way I understand it they were on the same tree as a.but he is saying dog a made some barks off the tree then came back to it with the the other dogs.

__________________
__________________

Cats Cove Kennels
Ntch,Grch. Timber Cruizin' Carlie
'PR'NTCH,Ch. Swampmusic Bear HTX ( Wtda Ntch,Ch)
Mad Cats Thunder Bella ( MTN Cur){Wtda Sqch,Tree Ch,Ch. World show ch.}

quote:

---

Originally posted by joey
To minus B and C for treeing after the 5 they have to be found treed with A. They were not and sense the judge did not determine that they were treed on the same tree as A then they are plussed.

---

__________________
Everything that makes them a COONDOG is on the inside

quote:

---

Originally posted by GA DAWG
Thats a tough one. One big mess and I could see it happening.. My question is what's considered judge arriving at the tree. Is it when you can see it? That could be 100 yards or more in winter.

---